"What shall be done with the four million slaves if they are emancipated? ... Primarily, it is a question less for man than for God -- less for human intellect than for the laws of nature to solve. It assumes that nature has erred; that the law of liberty is a mistake; that freedom, though a natural want of the human soul, can only be enjoyed at the expense of human welfare, and that men are better off in slavery than they would or could be in freedom; that slavery is the natural order of human relations, and that liberty is an experiment. What shall be done with them? Our answer is, do nothing with them; mind your business, and let them mind theirs. Your doing with them is their greatest misfortune. They have been undone by your doings, and all they now ask, and really have need of at your hands, is just to let them alone. They suffer by every interference, and succeed best by being let alone." ~ Frederick Douglass
A Proof of Anarchy: The Rulers Themselves
Column by Paul Bonneau.
Exclusive to STR
Day after day we read that cops or other minions of the ruling class never suffer any legal consequences for various and sundry vile actions on their part. No doubt you can find an example today and every day among the Strike The Root articles.
One working definition of government might as well be, “those people for whom the laws do not, in any real sense, apply.”
It struck me after reading one of these articles, that the rulers are themselves leading an anarchic existence! No law applies to them. Yet, they do not experience chaos in their personal lives. They do not murder their fellows over disagreements.
Of course this is not a perfect proof of anarchy, because there are in fact millions who have been murdered by the rulers, primarily those rulers in the United States in recent years. But let us not forget, this is an anarchic society of criminals, psychopaths and sociopaths. The worst do indeed get on top, as Hayek noted. It would be entirely unrealistic to expect such a society, full of evil bastards drunk on power, not to use it badly. Ordinary people in the same position probably would not be quite so lethal to innocent others.
Also, humans are tribal. Those outside the tribe do have to watch out. No matter who is in the tribe of rulers, those outside that tribe must always be at risk. The remedy is to join another tribe with some teeth....
But still, one gets some sense that the rulers do prove anarchy. They do not usually murder and rape their associates. For those others they do murder, rape and torture, it’s not anarchy that is at fault, but the power they have over others. Disparities in power seem to be the true enemies of an anarchic existence.
If this is so, it would behoove anarchists to get their hands on some, to start reducing this disparity.