The Lands Between have expanded drastically, and with the monumental release of the Shadow of the Erdtree expansion, players have rushed back to the game to test out hundreds of new armaments. If you are looking to optimize your build for the grueling bosses of the Land of Shadow, scouring community discussions is standard practice. Specifically, players turn to Reddit to find the ultimate new elden ring weapons tier list updates. The community consensus on the best Elden Ring DLC weapons is constantly shifting as players discover hyper-optimized builds, hidden scaling secrets, and unexpected poise-breaking mechanics.
In this comprehensive guide, we will break down the meta, analyze the community's favorite tools of destruction, and synthesize the collective wisdom found across various Elden Ring Reddit tier lists. Whether you prefer colossal greatswords, lightning-fast hand-to-hand martial arts, or arcane-scaling status effect injectors, understanding where these items rank will save you countless hours of trial and error.
---
Understanding the Reddit Meta for Elden Ring DLC Weapons
Reddit has always been a battleground for theorycrafting, meme builds, and serious algorithmic optimization. When it comes to the new elden ring weapons tier list reddit threads, opinions range wildly from casual explorers to hardcore speedrunners. However, patterns quickly emerge. A weapon's placement in the S-tier usually depends on a few specific criteria: speed of recovery, staggering potential, status buildup efficiency, and the utility of its unique Ash of War.
Unlike the base game, where bleed builds dominated for years, the expansion introduced entirely new weapon classes that completely changed how players approach combat. Categories like Light Greatswords, Backhand Blades, Perfume Bottles, and Beast Claws have redefined movement in combat. The general consensus on subreddits like r/Eldenring and r/EldenRingBuilds is that flexibility and hyper-armor frames are king in the DLC. Bosses attack relentlessly, leaving very small windows for retaliation, which heavily penalizes slow, committal animations unless they deal astronomical stagger damage.
---
S-Tier: The Absolute Best Elden Ring Weapons According to Reddit
When sorting through upvoted tier lists, a few standout weapons consistently claim the top spots. These armaments make notoriously difficult bosses manageable through sheer offensive output or defensive utility.
Backhand Blades and Blind Spot
If there is one weapon class that united the Reddit Elden Ring community in absolute praise, it is the Backhand Blades. Found early in the expansion, these weapons offer incredible agility. The default Ash of War, Blind Spot, allows you to sidestep an enemy's attack while simultaneously delivering a devastating counter-thrust.
- Unmatched attack speed for a melee weapon.
- Blind Spot provides built-in iframe evasion during the strike.
- Scales exceptionally well with Keen, Heavy, or Status infusions.
- Low stamina consumption allows for aggressive combo chains.
Milady and Wing Stance
The Light Greatsword category introduced Milady, and it immediately captured the hearts of aesthetic-focused players and min-maxers alike. Paired with the Wing Stance Ash of War, this weapon delivers sweeping, graceful combos that bridge the gap between straight swords and heavy greatswords. Reddit users frequently highlight its incredible reach and the fact that its heavy follow-up attacks can easily catch rolling players in PvP and stagger aggressive PvE mobs.
---
A-Tier: Niche Powerhouses and Status Masters
While S-tier weapons offer universal utility, A-tier options are incredibly powerful within specific builds. Many players on Reddit argue that certain A-tier weapons can easily outperform S-tier choices if paired with the correct talisman setup and stat distribution.
Bloodfiend's Arm
Before subsequent patches adjusted its scaling, the Bloodfiend's Arm was considered utterly broken. Even after balancing, this colossal weapon remains a staple on any new elden ring weapons tier list reddit thread. It scales heavily with Arcane and inflicts massive blood loss buildup per swing. Because heavy jump attacks with this weapon deal staggering amounts of physical and status damage, it trivializes many of the expansion's hardest encounters.
Rellana's Twin Blades
As a remembrance weapon, Rellana's Twin Blades carry a lot of hype. While they require a demanding stat spread across Strength, Dexterity, Intelligence, and Faith, mastering their complex moveset yields incredible elemental versatility. Reddit threads often debate their ranking; while difficult to use effectively due to long animation locks, players who master the stance transitions find them to be visually stunning and mathematically devastating.
---
B-Tier and C-Tier: Fun, Flawed, and Specialized Armaments
Not every new weapon can be a meta-defining powerhouse. A significant portion of the Elden Ring DLC weapons tier list discussions focus on items that are undeniably fun to use, but suffer from mechanical shortcomings such as high stat requirements, poor tracking, or sluggish recovery frames.
Perfume Bottles
At launch, certain Perfume Bottles (specifically bugged interactions with rolling sparks) were considered the most overpowered items in the game, dominating every tier list. Once patched, they plummeted to earth. However, they remain a unique addition. While standard usage can feel underwhelming compared to traditional magic or melee options, they still offer great elemental coverage for niche builds.
The Thorns of Sin and Sorceries
Though technically spells rather than weapons, catalysts and glintstone staves frequently share space on weapon tier lists due to their scaling mechanics. The community generally agrees that while flashy, pure faith-based projectile setups require too much setup time compared to simply using a reliable melee weapon with a great Ash of War.
---
How to Choose the Right Weapon for Your Playstyle
Reading a new elden ring weapons tier list reddit post can be inspiring, but building your character solely based on someone else's S-tier list might lead to frustration. The Lands Between reward adaptability. If you prefer a slow, methodical playstyle centered around guard counters and colossal staggering, a top-tier dex weapon like the Backhand Blades might feel too frantic. Conversely, if you love dodging through boss combos and punishing openings with rapid strikes, heavy colossal weapons will feel painfully sluggish.
When evaluating your loadout, consider the following factors:
- Stat Investment: Do you want to respec, or do you need a weapon that fits your current level 150 or 200 build?
- Boss Matchups: Some bosses are immune to status effects like bleed or frostbite, making raw physical or elemental burst damage much more valuable.
- PvE vs. PvP: A weapon that dominates in PvE through high stance damage might have terrible tracking against human opponents in the Colosseum.
---
Community Sentiment and Future Balance Patches
FromSoftware is notorious for altering the meta with regular balance patches. Weapons that sit comfortably at the top of a reddit elden ring tier list today might get nerfed tomorrow, while underperforming weapons often receive much-needed buffs. This dynamic nature keeps the community active, argumentative, and constantly experimenting.
Reddit remains the best pulse-check for the game's evolving meta. By engaging with community discussions, sharing your own findings, and keeping an eye on updated video essays and community spreadsheets, you ensure your Tarnished is always equipped to face whatever horrors the Shadow Realm throws your way. Experiment with different upgrade stones, test out experimental Ashes of War, and don't be afraid to take a B-tier weapon to victory if its moveset simply clicks with your personal gaming style.
---
FAQ
Q: What is currently considered the best weapon in Elden Ring according to Reddit?
A:While the meta frequently shifts due to patches, Backhand Blades and the Bloodfiend's Arm consistently claim the top spots on nearly every major Reddit tier list due to their exceptional speed, status buildup, and staggering capabilities.
Q: Are the DLC weapons usable in the base game of Elden Ring?
A:Yes! Once you acquire weapons in the Shadow of the Erdtree expansion, you can freely use them anywhere in the base game, provided you meet the required stat attributes to wield them.
Q: Why do Reddit tier lists change so often?
A:FromSoftware frequently releases balance patches that adjust weapon scaling, animation speeds, and bugged interactions (such as unintended damage scaling on perfume bottles), causing dramatic shifts in community rankings.
Q: Do I need to level up my character differently for DLC weapons?
A:Many new weapon classes introduce hybrid scaling requirements—such as Intelligence and Faith, or Arcane and Strength. You may need to visit Rennala to reallocate your attribute points to properly utilize the best expansion armaments.
Q: Where can I find the most accurate community tier lists?
A:Subreddits like r/Eldenring, r/EldenRingBuilds, and community-driven Google spreadsheets linked within these forums are the best places to find up-to-date, peer-reviewed weapon rankings.
Q: Are status effect builds still the meta in the Elden Ring expansion?
A:Bleed and Frost remain extremely powerful, but the expansion also heavily rewards physical stagger builds, heavy jump attacks, and elemental hybrid setups due to the aggressive nature of DLC bosses.
